Founder-owned home care franchise with full P&L disclosure but state-mandated financial warning — DO NOT PROCEED recommendation
Franchises · Non Medical Franchises · FDD 2026
Full affiliate P&L disclosure (46.5% GM, 11.1% net) and individual franchisee revenue by location — best transparency in category. But STATE-MANDATED financial warning, 3-year profit collapse, and pending fraud lawsuit make this a DO NOT PROCEED.
Non-Medical Home Care, Personal Care, Companion Care (Agency Model — W-2 Caregivers)
A Better Solution (ABS) shows strong revenue ($595K median) across a growing system of 30 US outlets. No P&L is disclosed, so profit estimates rely on industry benchmarks. The key question is whether the franchisor can sustain support quality as the system grows.
Median franchise earns $595K/year in gross revenue
Steady growth from 27 to 30 outlets — stable expansion without overextension
11.3% 3-year average (highest in dataset) annual churn rate — higher than average. Investigate why franchisees are leaving.
ABS has the best financial transparency in home care (full affiliate P&L, no gag clauses, individual revenues by location) but the worst franchisor financial health (state-mandated warning, 3-year profit collapse, $197K equity, pending fraud lawsuit). It's the opposite tradeoff from ComForCare: maximum transparency, minimum franchisor stability. Not recommended until lawsuit resolves and financials stabilize.
Our assessments reflect independent analysis of publicly-filed Franchise Disclosure Documents, state registration disclosures, and court filings. This is not legal, financial, or investment advice. Franchisors may submit corrections through our vendor portal.
This is the single most important question. The data below comes directly from the franchise's legally required disclosure document (FDD Item 19).
The typical franchisee earns $595K/year in gross revenue. The top performer at $2.3M pulls the average up, so plan for the median, not the mean.
This is above the typical median for non-medical home care franchises ($400K-$600K range).
Average Revenue
$811K
Median Revenue
$595K
More reliable benchmark
Top Performer
$2.3M
Bottom Performer
Not disclosed
Why this matters for you:
What percentage of franchisees reach each revenue level? This tells you how realistic each target is.
Revenue is gross billings, not profit. After caregiver payroll, overhead, and franchise fees, owner profit is typically 10-25% of gross revenue.
2 of 23 franchisees (9%) are in the highest revenue band (Under $250K), while 6 (26%) are in the lowest (Over $1M).
A healthy system has most franchisees in the middle bands. Heavy clustering at the bottom is a warning sign.
Estimated using industry benchmark margins (no P&L disclosed by this franchise)
At median franchise revenue ($595K), the estimated owner take-home is roughly $145K/year — including a $50K owner salary.
A reasonable return, competitive with salaried management roles while building equity.
Revenue is not profit. This table translates gross revenue into estimated owner take-home using industry benchmark margins. The highlighted row is closest to the median revenue ($595K).
| Revenue | Gross Profit | Est. Net | Owner Take-Home |
|---|---|---|---|
| $250K | $105K | $40K | $90K |
| $500K | $210K | $80K | $130K |
| $595KMEDIAN | $250K | $95K | $145K |
| $750K | $315K | $120K | $170K |
| $1.0M | $420K | $160K | $210K |
| $1.5M | $630K | $240K | $290K |
| $2.0M | $840K | $320K | $370K |
Gross margin: 42% | Est. overhead: 20% | Franchise fees: 6% | Owner salary: $50K added
Margins estimated from industry benchmarks. Your results will depend on market, management, and tenure.
Outlet count, growth trajectory, and churn — signals of system health
Moderate, steady growth — the system is expanding without overextending. A balanced signal.
Steady growth suggests the franchisor is being selective about new franchisees, which typically means better support per franchise.
What this means for you:
Upfront investment, ongoing fees, and minimum performance requirements
What you need to write checks for before earning your first dollar.
3-month working capital in FDD is shortest disclosure — likely understates true need by 50-80%.
Key metrics that signal whether franchisees in this system tend to succeed or struggle.
Small system — less track record
Net outlet growth over 3 years
Terminations + closures as % of total system
Franchise agreements signed but never operationalized
Transfers suggest a liquid resale market — good for exit planning
What fraction of franchisees actually hit the system average
Combined royalty + ad fund is 6% of gross revenue — below average, leaving you with more of each dollar earned.
These recurring fees come off the top of your revenue every month, regardless of profitability.
These fees are deducted before you see any profit. At $500K revenue with 6% combined fees, that's $30K/year going to the franchisor — before you pay rent, staff, or yourself.
Complexity, risk scoring, and key signals to watch
High complexity franchise — requires experienced management. The biggest challenge area is financial risk (10/10).
Each dimension scored 1-10. Higher = more complex or risky. The shape shows where this franchise's challenges concentrate.
More watch items than strengths — pay extra attention to the risk factors below. (5 strengths, 9 watch items)
Your franchise is only as strong as the company behind it. A weak franchisor can't deliver on training, marketing, or technology promises — regardless of how good the business model is.
A financially weak franchisor may struggle to provide training, marketing, technology, and ongoing support. If they can't sustain themselves, your investment is at risk regardless of your own performance.
Overview, fees, territory, training, and raw data tables
Legal Entity
ABS Franchise Services, Inc.
State of Organization
California
Headquarters
8929 Complex Drive, San Diego, California 92123
Business Model
Agency Model. Commercial office required (125-500 sq ft). Two FTE from day one (Director of Business Development + Staffing Manager).
Parent Company
NONE — founder-owned (Lillia Smith-Pratt). NOT PE-backed. No external board oversight.
Franchise Fee
$55,000 (uniform, non-refundable)
Total Investment
$126,890 – $235,350
Royalty
5% (drops to 4.75% at $1M, 4.5% at $2M)
Marketing
1% or $250/month minimum
Veteran Discount: $5,000 off IFF
Technology Fee: $299/month (up to 10% annual increases)
DO NOT PROCEED at this time for any buyer category. The franchisor-level default risk over the 10-year contract materially outweighs the affiliate's genuine operational quality. WAIT 12-18 months to observe lawsuit resolution, 2026 financials, and return to positive cash flow.
Situation
ABS is a 30-outlet founder-owned California home care franchisor with $1.1M annual franchisor revenue — roughly the size of a single mid-tier franchisee. Median revenue $595K. Investment $127K-$235K.
Complication
Four issues converge: (1) State-mandated financial warning. (2) Three-year profitability collapse to net loss, operating cash flow negative 2 years. (3) Pending fraud lawsuit seeking rescission (trial Oct 2026) with $0 accrued against $197K equity. (4) Mandatory spousal guarantee + $50K+ liquidated damages + 5-day cure — punitive contract terms.
Upgrade Trigger
Day Venture resolves favorably + 2026 FDD shows return to operating cash flow positive + state financial warning removed from 2027 FDD.
Downgrade Trigger
Plaintiffs win rescission or material damages + auditor issues going concern + SBA loan acceleration + additional franchisee lawsuits.
Track: lawsuit resolution, audited financials, state warning status, system growth, equity level.
Alleges franchise misrepresented as "100% passive business model." Same litigation theory as Griswold's $700K California class settlement and $4.2M Louisiana arbitration.
Litigation Summary
1 pending action (Day Venture fraud lawsuit, trial Oct 2026). Plaintiffs allege promissory estoppel, breach of contract, false advertising, fraudulent inducement, fraud, constructive fraud, Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code violation, negligence.
Affiliate-owned locations
Average
46.5%
2 affiliate-owned locations
Full P&L: $6.5M gross sales, $3.0M gross profit (46.5%), $1.9M operating expenses, $1.09M net ordinary income (16.7%), $722K adjusted net (11.1% after hypothetical royalties). 25-year founder operation across 4 territories — ceiling, not median expectation.
At median revenue
Estimates based on disclosed affiliate gross margin and industry benchmark operating expenses. Not disclosed by franchisor.
Cost to launch
3-month working capital in FDD is shortest disclosure — likely understates true need by 50-80%.
What franchisees earn
Avg Revenue
$810,814
Median Revenue
$595,052
Gross Margin
46.5% (disclosed)%
Est. ODCF
$50,000-$150,000 at median revenue
Above $500K
56%
Full affiliate P&L disclosed (rare). Franchisee margins estimated below affiliate level. Median revenue 30% below ComForCare and 55% below Griswold.
Term
10 years (renewal: 10yr then 5yr)
Renewal
25% of then-current franchise fee (~$13,750)
Non-Compete
24 months / 20 miles of ANY ABS franchise owner (wider than Griswold 1yr/20mi)
Disputes
Mediation → binding arbitration in California. California law.
Financing
No franchisor financing, direct or indirect.
Territory
Custom geographic territory (no standard population/senior formula). Performance standard: $250K annual after 24 months.
Exclusivity
Genuinely protected — ABS will not use internet, catalog, or direct marketing inside your territory. More franchisee-favorable than ComForCare or Griswold.
vs. Griswold
Griswold: 182 outlets, $1.42M single-territory avg, 4% royalty, $23M franchisor revenue. ABS: 30 outlets, $595K median, 5% royalty, $1.1M revenue. Griswold wins on revenue, fees, and scale. Both have franchisor financial concerns but Griswold has $15M equity cushion vs ABS's $197K.
vs. ComForCare
ComForCare: 270 outlets, $1.3M avg, $20M franchisor revenue, PE-backed. ABS: 30 outlets, $811K avg, $1.1M franchisor revenue, founder-owned. ComForCare has 9x the outlets and 17x the franchisor revenue.
vs. HomeInstead
Home Instead: 619 outlets, $2.6M avg. ABS is 1/20th the size with less than 1/4 the revenue. Not comparable in scale.
Performance Variance Warning
Only 26% of franchisees meet the $811K average. Median is $595K. Top 3 average $2.04M while bottom 3 average $206K (9.9x ratio). Two outlets below $250K performance standard. DO NOT extrapolate from affiliate's $6.5M or system average.
A deeper look at the specific advantages and risks of this franchise, based on FDD analysis.
A Better Solution (ABS) is a small, founder-owned non-medical home care franchise with 30 outlets. STATE-MANDATED WARNING: regulators found the franchisor financially questionable to provide services. Median franchisee revenue $595K. Full affiliate P&L disclosed (46.5% gross margin, 11.1% net). 3-year profitability collapse and pending fraud lawsuit. DO NOT PROCEED recommendation.
Founded
2000
Employees
10-50
Headquarters
San Diego, CA
Training
Included
Lillia Smith-Pratt
Founder & Owner (both ABS Franchise Services and affiliate)
Kurt Buske
President
Dylan Sambuceti
VP Franchise Development
Tim Valencia
VP Franchise Development
Caring Senior Service
Home Instead
The world's largest non-medical home care franchise — 1,243 global locations, $2.6M average revenue, 30 years of franchising, backed by Honor Technology's Care Platform
1Heart Caregiver Services
Non-medical home care franchise with $2M affiliate P&L disclosure, tiered pricing from $60K, 47% gross margin, and strong California market presence
Assisting Hands Home Care
Non-medical & medical home care franchise — 207 outlets, graduated royalty (4-5%), $55K franchise fee, Area Representative support model
Claim this listing to update your profile, add details, and connect with potential customers.
Claim This Listing